Original Derek Replacement’s Grey’s Anatomy Season 21 Return Could Disrupt Meredith’s Life

Meredith’s love life seems finally settled in Grey's Anatomy season 21 after Derek’s death, but the potential return of one character could cause disruption in Meredith’s life. Among Grey’s Anatomy’s most shocking deaths of a main character, Derek’s ranks high because of how heartbreakingly it was brought forth, with his saving all his patients before dying because the surgeon on call didn’t order the tests that could have saved him, and because of how it massively impacted Meredith. For some time, dating felt impossible for Meredith, reeling from the loss and the fact the love of her life had died.

Eventually, Meredith started dating again and even formed major romantic relationships. However, they all felt like the relationship potential was untapped. Indeed, Meredith’s relatively long bond with Andrew DeLuca fizzled out after Andrew realized Meredith didn’t love him as she did being a surgeon. Cormac Hayes, Nathan Riggs and Atticus Lincoln were all considered possible romantic partners for Meredith, but all their relationships or attempts at such with Meredith were somewhat unfulfilled. Nick and Meredith’s relationship is the first to hold up compared to her and Derek’s, but one character potentially returning in Grey’s Anatomy season 21 could disrupt it.

Nathan Riggs' Return Could Poke Even More Holes In Meredith & Nick's Romance

Grey's Anatomy Seasons 19 & 20 Already Showed Their Many Problems

Riggs flirts with Meredith inside a ward in Grey's Anatomy

Scott Speedman as Nick Marsh & Ellen Pompeo as Meredith Grey in a doorway in Grey's Anatomy

Meredith and Riggs on Grey's Anatomy

Ellen Pompeo as Meredith Grey and Scott Speedman as Nick Marsh in Grey's Anatomy S19

Ellen Pompeo as Meredith Grey smiling at another doctor on Grey's Anatomy (2005) Season 21

Among Derek’s replacements as Meredith’s love interests, Nathan Riggs was the first to appear in Grey’s Anatomy season 12 precisely for that reason. While Meredith and Nathan eventually connected, their relationship was truncated the moment Owen’s sister and Nathan’s ex-fiancée Megan was found alive overseas, making it impossible for Meredith and Nathan’s connection to be explored as Megan’s return evidently trumped what they could have had. Martin Henderson not excluding a possible return to Grey’s Anatomy as Nathan Riggs thus makes him a potential disruption in Meredith’s life and relationship with Nick, even more so after Nathan and Megan’s breakup.

Meredith and Nick’s relationship is stabler than ever in Grey’s Anatomy season 21. Meredith’s outburst about Bailey’s health in season 20 forced her also to admit her feelings, thus prompting Meredith to be open at last with Nick. This strengthened their relationship, but Grey’s Anatomy season 19 and 20 already showed their problems, including Meredith’s tendency to keep Nick in the dark about her Grey Sloan issues. Her refusal to admit her feelings led to Nick almost abandoning her multiple times. Nathan’s arrival could exacerbate them by offering an alternative, effectively being among the ones who got away.

Grey's Anatomy Ruined Riggs' Perfect LA Ending When It Unnecessarily Separated Him & Megan

Meredith & Riggs Couldn't Happen Because Megan Was Revealed To Be Alive

Abigail Spencer as Megan Hunt and Martin Henderson as Nathan Riggs in Grey's Anatomy

Henderson addressing how he would only return as Nathan in Grey’s Anatomy if the story truly warranted it excludes a comeback solely to spread discord between Nick and Meredith. His return could nonetheless be worthwhile, as coming back in Grey’s Anatomy season 21 or even later could finally tell Nathan’s side of his breakup with Megan, something unbelievably cruel that the medical drama sprung on Megan and Nathan after Nathan’s Grey’s Anatomy exit perfectly included his and Megan happily ever after, trying to build a life together with Farouk in LA.

While Megan’s return had the downside of leaving Meredith and Nathan’s possible relationship unexplored, it was a massive opportunity for Megan and Nathan’s relationship. After everything they went through in their past, including Nathan’s betrayal and Megan getting on the helicopter that was downed only because she was angry at him, Nathan and Megan’s reconnection and wish to build a life together was a message of hope and second chances. Season 18 revealing his and Megan’s offscreen breakup thus felt especially cruel, making Nathan’s return to Grey’s Anatomy necessary even just for giving him the chance to say his piece.

Episode #

Title

Release Date

1

If Walls Could Talk

September 26, 2024

2

Take Me to Church

October 3, 2024

3

I Can See Clearly Now

October 10, 2024

4

This One's for the Girls

October 17, 2024

5

You Make My Heart Explode

October 24, 2024

6

Night Moves

November 8, 2024

7

If You Leave

November 15, 2024

8

Drop It Like It's Hot

November 22, 2024

9

TBA

March 6, 2025

Related Posts

Katherine Heigl Says ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Ghost Sex Was ‘Confusing,’ Reunites With Jeffrey Dean Morgan to Discuss ‘Awkward’ Storyline: ‘She’s F—ing a Dead Guy?’

Katherine Heigl and Jeffrey Dean Morgan reunited for the first time in years as part of Entertainment Weekly’s 20th anniversary of Shondaland and got brutally honest about…

It’s a Beautiful Day to Relive Grey’s Anatomy’s Most Epic Romances

Dead wrong, as well, because fans have consistently tuned in since the March 27, 2005, premiere to watch as Meredith and an ever-growing collection of surgeons, nurses,…

I Tried Link’s Unusual Breakfast Sandwich From Grey’s Anatomy—Here’s What I Thought

Some foods are a match made in heaven, while others are just… questionable. Grey’s Anatomy fans got a taste of the latter in a recent episode when Link, played…

Ellen Pompeo Reveals the Iconic ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Line She Almost Didn’t Say

It’s been two years since Ellen Pompeo took a step back from her iconic portrayal of Meredith Grey in Shonda Rhimes’ medical drama Grey’s Anatomy. And though…

Grey’s Anatomy: Meredith Bets on Herself, Owen and Teddy Make an Unconventional Choice and 1 Couple Don’t See Eye to Eye

Warning: this story contains spoilers from the March 27 episode of Grey's Anatomy. Meredith Grey (Ellen Pompeo) wouldn’t take no for an answer on Grey’s Anatomy.  While…

OMG, I Can’t Believe It Has Been 10 Years Since Derek Shepherd Died In Grey’s Anatomy

Derek’s death in Grey's Anatomy was easily among the show’s most heartbreaking, changing it forever because of what it meant for Meredith, and it happening ten years…